Maygan Barclay Bayles
February 24, 1984 ~ June 5, 2021
Maygan Barclay Bayles, 37, left this life Saturday, June 5, 2021 at Franciscan Health Indianapolis. Maygan was born February 24, 1984 in Provo, Utah to loving parents Thomas Ray and Christy Jo Ellis Barclay.
She is a wife, a sister, an aunt, a daughter, a teacher, a gymnastics coach, a friend, and a Child of God. She is energetic, driven, spunky, full of life, and gave her all at anything she endeavored. A lifetime member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints and has a personal testimony of the Gospel. She has a deep understanding of Father’s plan and that families are forever. She loved to teach it to the younger generations to carry on God’s word.
Throughout her childhood Maygan loved many sports including gymnastics, cheerleading, soccer, volleyball, basketball, and swimming. After high school, she attended IUPUI and graduated in 2010 with a Bachelor’s Degree in Elementary Education. She taught in IPS, Warren, and Franklin Central Townships.
She was blessed to find the love of her life, Joseph Alan Bayles and they were sealed on December 12, 2015 in the Indianapolis Temple. They made their home in Indianapolis, Indiana. She loved the beach, “glamping”, playing games, hiking, singing, dancing, musicals, and spending time with friends and family. Her husband and her family were the center of her world and she loved them with her whole heart. She loved all children and would do anything for her nieces, nephews, her gymnasts, and her students.
Maygan possessed many talents including playing trumpet and piano, cooking, and baking. She was known for her butterscotch cupcakes and caramel popcorn. She was a talented artist and loved crafting, drawing, and painting, and mastered anything she tried. She was always willing to open her home to all.
Maygan is survived by her husband, Joseph Bayles; her parents, Thomas and Christy Barclay; her grandfather, Larry Ellis; her brothers, Jed (Robbyn) Barclay of Bloomington, Aaron Barclay, and Chris (Kara Paul) Barclay, both of Indianapolis; her sisters, Jenny (Michael) Oden of Greenwood; Kim (Matt) Wilke of Oolitic, Indiana, Natalie (JR) Clark of Morgantown, and Sarah (Chris) Schooley of Hope; and her nieces and nephews, Jayare, Jaylynn, Jayce, and Jay Rush Clark, Charlie, Sumner, Waylin, and Tess Barclay, Chaela Castro, Addison and Spencer James, and Lincoln Bayles.
She was preceded in death by her grandparents, Carolyn Smith Ellis, Michael Barclay, and Ruth Howell Barclay.
A funeral service for Maygan will be held Thursday, June 10 at 11 a.m. at The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (3330 30th St. Columbus, IN 47203) with Bishop Jonathan Merrell officiating. Burial will take place at New Harmony Cemetery in Bartholomew County.
Visitation will be held Wednesday, June 9 from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m. at Jewell-Rittman Family Funeral Home. Additional visitation will be one hour prior to the service on Thursday, from 10 a.m. to 11 a.m. at the church. Memorial Donations may be made through:
https://paypal.me/JosephBayles?locale.x=en_US
Maygan will always be remembered for the love she radiated. She was loved by all, loved all, and a Child of God above all.
The funeral service will be broadcast on Zoom. ZOOM Stream: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87192623798 / Meeting ID: 871 9262 3798
View current weather.
Memories Timeline
Photo Gallery
Guestbook
Sign the Guestbook, Light a Candle
Mahgan will be sadly missed by so many people. She really truly touched our hearts & lives! She loved her gymnasts girls and cared about each and every one of them and helped them with their skills to move up to next level or to win in competition. I will never forget the baking that she would do and bring in for the girls, the chocolate pops on a
stick!! She was a Great Coach and she was a Special Coach at TGC with my girls Kristin & Jenn! Know that we are praying for you Christy, your family & her husband❤️❤️✨✨✨😢😢 Love Gessling Girls
Jim, Lisa and Abby Hollenbaugh purchased the Simply Elegant Spathiphyllum for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Maygan had the best laugh, smile and heart of anyone I’ve known. God called her to early. She will always be a bright spot in my heart.
Peaceful White Lilies Basket was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Peaceful White Lilies Basket was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Simply Elegant Spathiphyllum was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Full Of Love Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Guiding Light Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Beautiful Heart Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Mrs Bayles was one of a kind…💜
My son started his 5th grade year this year & at the beginning of the year she had sent out an email to each parent stating how she would like to know a little more about each individual child. No teacher has done this prior. Mrs Bayles took the time to read, & respond to my email with a heartfelt message. 🤍
As a parent this gave me so much relief in knowing Mrs Bayles cared about my child more than just another student walking through those doors.
Deepest Condolences sent to the Bayles family and friends. We’re Praying for you all. 💜💜💜
Love, Bryson Perez & Family
Lovely One Spathiphyllum Plant was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Beautiful Dreams was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
A New Sunrise Spray was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Full Of Love Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Beautiful in Blue was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Full Of Love Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
I’m sure Mrs. Bayles had many, MANY success stories. She was a dedicated, energetic teacher who helped the kids get excited to learn. My son, Cole came into Mrs. Bayles’ 5th grade class not wanting to learn. He was nervous after all the unknown, starting a new school in a difficult time, and the last thing on his mind was Math. Mrs. Bayles met him right where he was. She didn’t see a little boy refusing to work, but she saw a confused/anxious little boy with all the potential, but just not ready to learn yet. At the end of the year, she called him her success story. This is because Mrs. Bayles believed in him, kept pouring into him, and never gave up on him.
I am deeply sorry for your loss. I hope you never forget how many lives your very special loved one has touched.
I remember laughing with Maygan every time I was with her. Sleepovers at the gym where we stayed up late with friends playing, laughing, and talking. Right before I moved we went for a walk and we promised to keep in touch…I regret that we didn’t. I saw Maygan again at the Indianapolis Temple open house and she came over and said we saw this lady and thought “WOAH SHES PREGNANT…then said OH ITS ALLYSA! ” She ran over we hugged and talked like we hadn’t skipped a beat. That is Maygan! She was and is a friend to all. Someone you could go years without seeing and pick right back up where you left off. She was warm, happy, and funny! My heart is sad knowing that she is gone from this life! I look forward to when I can see her again! Maygan I’ll bring the Hawaiian Sammy shirts so we can take a picture and laugh about it again! My sweet friend, you are loved and will be terribly missed!
Judy (Zook) Dudley and Family purchased the Enchanted Cottage for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Love, Lynn Lykins and Family purchased the Arrive in Style for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
I’m so sorry. I will keep your family in my prayers.
Beautiful in Blue was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Sweet Tenderness was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Be My Love Bouquet with Red Roses was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Gary & Carolyn Fish and Spencer & Amy Fish purchased the Lavender Reflections Spray for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Beautiful Heart Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Florist Choice Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Sweet Solace Spray was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Beautiful Heart Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Treasured Lilies Spray was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
LOVE KRISTIN, JENN & MEL GESSLING purchased the Crystal Cross Bouquet for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
I remember when Maygan joined my 4th grade team at Kitley Elementary. She quickly became my friend. Even though we were very different in a lot of ways, we were alike in all the ones that mattered. Maygan was a very positive person who loved to have fun. She connected with students in a very meaningful way. I respected how she always shared her true feelings and didn’t put on a show for anyone! She was always the first one to offer to help anyone or open her home. Her delicious treats and creative ideas were amazing. She was so fun to work with! When we parted ways and went to different schools I was sad to not have her as a part of my everyday life. She always made me laugh and truly cared about my family. I also loved hearing stories about her family. She loved them so much! Every time I play a board game, try a new great recipe, or travel somewhere fun I will think of Maygan. My family and I will talk about her and remember her often. She was truly one of the good ones and I will miss her so much!
Beautiful Heart Bouquet was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
All of my memories of Maygan involve her big smile, laugh, and positive attitude. As a teacher, coach, friend, niece, cousin, sister, daughter, and neighbor, Maygan positively influenced a lot of people. I am heartbroken that her life was cut short at such a young age. My condolences to all of the people who were close to her, especially her family and husband Joe. May we all honor her memory by trying to be a positive influence on those around us like she was. Love, Uncle Michael
An external video has been added.
Fairest of All was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Country Basket Blooms was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
Peaceful White Lilies Basket was purchased for the family of Maygan Barclay Bayles.
SHE WAS BEAUTIFUL! THANK YOU FOR SHARING HER WITH US❤️
Most of my memories of Maygan include Kim. We were so close in age that it was usually the 3 of us. I remember one time we were going somewhere. I was driving and Maygan was in the front seat. Kim was in the back and we had all the windows down. Maygan and my hair was blowing perfectly back. We looked back at Kim and her hair was all over the place and we all just started laughing. I remember they taught me how to do a hand stand. My favorite memory of Maygan is when my friend invited us to go out on her dads boat. Kim and Maygan went with me, but when we got there Maygan decided she didn’t want to go on the boat. So she and I sat on the dock while Kim and my friend went out. We had the best conversation and I felt so close to her at that time. Even though we lived so far away from each other. I always feel so close to my cousins. I love you guys! Love Jess!
Maygan was a member of the Arlington school family for a year and she spread joy to those around her each and every day. She was always so calm and comforting to her students and I know that’s only one of the many reasons her students and coworkers loved her. She will always hold a special place in my heart and will never be forgotten.
Maygan, my dear friend that I considered one of the best! The memories were a time but the way you made me feel will be forever. Our gut laughter together still makes me smile: remember that time when we were eating chips and we started to laugh so hard a piece of chip flew out of your mouth and landed on one of my chips and before I could even stop myself, I ate my chip! We both knew it happened and we didn’t even care! Oh the memories flood my mind and I just smile. Until we meet again Maygan, I will continue to love and teach children as you did and love all unconditionally.
Love, “your helper” Vandi, as you were always the leader
Maygan was my mentor teacher and colleague. She has shown me how to be a better teacher, but also how to be an amazing human.
I only got to work with Maygan for one year at Arlington Elementary but what an impact she made. The sweetest soul and kindest smile. She was a blessing to everyone she met. After 5th grade graduation I was prepared to have to put up all of the folding chairs by myself (I was the Head Custodian). But that didn’t happen. Mrs Bayles kept her class late and had them help me without being asked. Always thinking of others. That’s who she was. Love you Maygan! Fly high sweet girl!
My favorite memory with Maygan involves a game of spoons. We both went to grab the last spoon on the table at the same time. There was no way Maygan was letting me have it without a fight. She lunged and, somehow, we both ended up on the floor with 2 broken chairs. I think it took a good half hour for us all to stop laughing! I’m glad someone snapped a photo to commemorate the event. Maygan’s joy and her spirit of friendly competition will be sorely missed.
Adanna Williams
Our hearts are breaking for you, Joe. Maygan was a pure joy to be around and she radiated light to all who were privileged to know her. Maygan will be deeply missed and we can’t wait until we can be with her again. You are in our thoughts and prayers. May Christ go before you, walk beside you, be in your midst, and be your rearward until you can be with your sweet Maygan again. We sure love you. Love, Jenny, Kaman, and crew.
Joey, we love you so very much. Our hearts are breaking for you. I was only able to meet Maygan a couple of times but I could tell right away just how amazing she was. She was sweet, funny and made everyone around her feel comfortable and special. I could tell that she had faith and was a strong believer in God’s plan.
I have so many memories of Maygan that I could never choose one. But the most important is that she always made me feel as if I mattered. Her family took me as an extra child when I needed it the most. They treat everyone as their own. I loved Maygan with all my heart and she will always be in my memories.
This photo is extra special because it came from Maygans phone. When I thought I had no pictures at all I was happy to have just found one on my computer but to have been given this second photo today was a real gift. Maygan’s smile is genuine. This wasn’t a smile just for the camera. She smiled often, was always happy to see a friend and invite them into her home and world. She always had a great story or caper to talk about that would keep us entertained and even laughing. I met Maygan and Kim before I ever even knew I would eventually move to Indianapolis. When my friend and I had moving truck trouble (maybe a tire issue I can’t remember) when I moved my things in Indy, with not a lot of warning they came to help us take things off the moving truck into a storage unit. Since that time these sisters and her husband Joe have become treasured friends. I have fun memories of the pontoon boat on Lake Monroe, listening to Imagine Dragons in the car and then going to the live concert with Maygan, Joe and friends. If you knocked on the door you were always welcome and she often wondered why you didn’t just walk in instead of knock. I have good memories of walking around the neighborhood, family home evenings, game nights, playing Kahoots for the first time with our phones and friends, dinner get togethers at El Meson, Oaken Barrel and O’Charleys. I love the sweet relationship of Maygan and Joe —good natured banter, laughter and even a little fun competitiveness. Maygan was the first person at church who I told about buying a new house. She was so excited for me and drove by it the next day. By the closing she was already in the fight of her life in the hospital so she didn’t get to see it in person but she saw the pictures and may have been even more excited than I was. Thank you Maygan for the friend and light that you are. Til we meet again wonderful friend.
Joey, as I’m remembering some things about Maygan. When I first met Maygan it was easy to see she was going to fit in with this Bayles bunch. She was beautiful, funny and she got all of our craziness. I remember most about how sweet she was and so excepting of everyone. Our talks about food and recipes for popcorn. The things we did together as a family. All the cookouts and fun we just had getting together at Grandpa’s . Just enjoying each others company. Going to Billy’s and Danielle’s for Lincolns blessing. How much fun we had playing game’s. How we talked about camping and I was so looking forward to our trip in September. Hopefully we will still go.
Though the next few day or months might be hard. You having a loving Heavenly Father that loves you and wants nothing more than to comfort and bless you. He will bring you peace an understanding. I love you with all my heart and I’m here for you cheering you on and praying for you.
Love Aunt Beth
Maygan was always one to reach out, to others. She loved meeting new people. At church always wanted to know who that new person was and become their friend. I have spent some significant time with Maygan and Joe over the last few years. They love their family and friends, they love the gospel, the daily interactions magnify the light of Christ to all those they meet. I have wonderful memories of car rides with the music blasting, people watching, game playing, crafting, and baking for others, opening her home to friends, including me. In the everyday of life, her happiness and laughter was contagious, she is a light, her smile, and friendship will be missed. I look forward to seeing her again, my sister, and friend. Love Sarah Carlson
Beautiful video♡
I had posted some of my thoughts on Facebook already but a sister mentioned that comments posted on this funeral home page would be made into a book for Maygan’s family and I didn’t want to pass up an opportunity to say again how wonderful she is.
For the last 6 years we taught and planned classes and activities together for the kids at our church. We belly ached a lot about it together, lol, but that was half the fun with Maygan – the friendly banter and joy that came from being around her. That and the fact that we often had our planning meetings doing something we both enjoyed: lounging at the pool. She loved the kids and seeing them have fun. She was easy to talk to… I think my kids would even say we talked too much, lol. We loved to play games with her. She came over many Sunday afternoons to beat us in card and board games. I think I made her late to family dinners more than once (Sorry!) We’re not really huggers in my family but my kids always had a hug for Maygan. I am a better person for knowing her. I feel blessed that our paths crossed in this life.
One of the memories I have of Maygan was one morning when I went to her house to drop something off. Even though I came kind of early and unannounced, she answered the door with a big smile on her face. She was in her pajamas, and I had to laugh because I have the same kind of muu muu dress grammy jammies. For some reason that image of Maygan answering her door that day is printed in my mind and I just think it shows how inviting and authentic Maygan is. She is one in a million.
Many memories of your beautiful daughter you Will always carry with you. Tom and Christy we are thinking of you and love you. The kaptains.
I have so many memories with Maygan, it’s hard just to choose one. We would laugh so much when we were together.
Maygan, Kim, I decided to start getting healthy together. Maygan got a Fitbit and became obsessed with getting her step goals. Everyone pitched in and bought me a Fitbit so we could challenge each other. We were constantly moving when we were together. She was determined to beat my goal. Lol! We would walk, mall walk, jog, P90x 3, go hiking, anything to get our steps.
Every time we would walk through the mall we would get stopped by this lady that worked at JC Penny’s. She was so impressed with Maygan and how hard she had worked to be healthy. Maygan was always determined to meet her goals. She was an amazing example to all of us.
Our road trips and hiking adventures were always so much fun. Our trips to Michigan were always filled interesting and funny stories, like how there was a big fight at the beach July 4th weekend and we all had to leave. We were so mad. We found another beach close by and made the best of it. There was never a dull moment when we were together. Even when we just sat around the living room talking. I could go on and on.
Several people thought Maygan, Kim, I were all sisters when we were together. I loved that so much. Maygan was a sister to me. I will always love Maygan, Joe, and her family. It’s hard saying goodbye, even though it’s temporary. We will see your sweet face again. I love you dear friend!